Page Options

Menu Styles:
MenuaMenubMenucMenud
Page width and font size:
Small width layoutMedium width layoutMaximum width layoutMaximum textMedium textSmall text
FORUM ADVICE

Should parents come to college graduation
Last Post 20 Aug 2010 07:48 PM by JudgeNeil. 3 Replies.
Printer Friendly
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
Author Messages
Avatar
Mallory



--
20 Aug 2010 07:42 PM
  • Quote
  • Reply
My parents want to come to my college graduation. I don't want to walk at graduation, since I've had a very bad time in college, and almost died. Everything's going to forever be screwed up because of the things I did here, and it's partly because I denied what was going on, and so did my parents.

1) is it wrong to not let them come? it is a lot of money, like 800$, to fly them out here.

2) Should I just talk to them instead of denying them this opportunity to see me graduate, even though it means virtually nothing, OR

3) Do I have a right to refuse to give into more of the crazy denial that caused all this, and in that sense have not walking be the right decision?

Thank you

Mallory (21F) from New York
Avatar
JudgeNeilUser is Offline Posts:394



--
20 Aug 2010 07:44 PM
  • Quote
  • Reply
Judge Neil's advice

Do not let the hardships of the past poison the potential tree of fruit of the future. While your college time may remind you of some very negative times, the graduation should be looked at as an end to those times and a beginning to your new life.

What makes the death penalty practically inapplicable in a fair manner in the justice system is the fact that it is irreversible. No matter how compelling the wisdom of hindsight is, it means nothing if the effects of a permanent decision cannot be corrected.

In your case, not attending your graduation falls into the same parallel. You will never have another chance to "walk". Your parents will never have the chance to see their "child" take that first real step into adulthood. Personally, I do not consider high school graduation the first step since most high school graduates are ill prepared to meet life's challenges.

From a basic business perspective, you have very little to lose by walking and much more to lose by not. Of course you ultimately should have and do have the the decision in your graduation. However, you did come here for my advice and my advice is this.

WALK. LET YOUR PARENTS COME. DON'T WORRY ABOUT WHY.

I hope you have a wonderful graduation, and congratulations!
Get live advice from me on Blog Talk Radio
*** Check my Blog Talk Radio page for show times!!!

www.JudgeNeil.com / www.FreeAdviceCenter.com
Avatar
Mallory



--
20 Aug 2010 07:46 PM
  • Quote
  • Reply
Hi-

Not to “appeal your decision” or anything, but if you get a chance, here’s some extra information on the question I asked; just wondering if you’d think any differently. Thanks!

So, college – I really can’t think of a good thing that happened here. In comparison to what I know I would have done at another school, anyway. What I did here was so selfish and wrong – and it really had serious consequences. I’m about to leave and consider myself worse off in every respect – socially, academically, as a person – than I was upon leaving high school: in your terms, I was more ready to enter the world than I am now (and I consider myself an optimist!).

I know I was the one who did all of this.

But y’know, I was just 18 and 19 at the time that things started to go awry – I was acting obnoxious as hell, just completely crazy, but God, I SO craved adult advice. ANY intervention would have helped at that point to prevent some of the downward spirling that happened later.

I mean, when I returned home, I (eventually) realized that I had totally incapacitated myself - couldn't write, read properly, socialize, was practically incapable of carrying on a conversation...

(Yes, I do know that it is crazy that I let it get this bad. I can only say that I really did not see what I was doing.)

My parents didn’t see or understand all of this – and they didn’t see how it happened. That I know. But they did see a LOT of the results.

I just can’t understand, on some level, why they were ok with leaving me like that. I mean, I know - *I* “left” myself like that. They did try to support me. But the utter preventability of the situation is so frustrating.

I got through this with the aid of a professor at school. Without that chance interaction, it’s likely that I would be dead. I really wish I were being overdramatic on this point, and I find the evil selfishness of it all detestably repulsive, beyond belief. **But do my parents not realize how serious this all was??**

It makes me crazy that they suddenly want to “celebrate” this as if it’s been anything like a “normal” or even *marginally ok* college education. If I refuse to let them come here, it would just be me saying ‘Agh, you are CRAZY! *HOW* can you think about celebrating this??’ It’s in that sense that it feels like “celebrating” my own death or something equally morbid and loony.

Their silence – yes, compounded with my *own decisions and equal silence/denial* – almost killed me. ?? How can I celebrate that?? I acknowledge what I did, my part in this…is it crazy to get them to acknowledge theirs? I mean, my parents are great parents, but not in the face of this insanity, and, apparently, not in the face of any type of real crisis situation involving myself or my sibling.

I KNOW how insane and irresponsible my actions were. ***I don’t have any desire to get into a situation of blaming my parents for what I did.*** And if you think I am doing that, have no hesitation to let me know.*

But I was relatively young, I could *really* have used some help; for them to suddenly come visit me at this point, when I needed them so badly before, feels like a form of complete insanity. Without the active intervention from that one professor, I’d probably be drunk or dead.

Ok, thanks for reading this far. Some final notes -

1) Wouldn’t it be better for them to “celebrate” something real? Have an optimism based in reality rather than this weird and crazy denial?

2) The most fruitful thing I can currently do is look to the future – and I do try to do that, but everything is overshadowed and just deeply screwed over, by everything I did here. How can I suddenly “forget” things and move past this?

3) I completely change my mind about this every few days: so I’d appreciate knowing what you think, if you have the time. If you think I’m being selfish & evil, or still think the same as before, let me know. Thanks again!
Avatar
JudgeNeilUser is Offline Posts:394



--
20 Aug 2010 07:48 PM
  • Quote
  • Reply
Judge Neil's reply

Thanks for your feedback, I really appreciate any additional information that might affect the advice I would tender.

You have somehow in your feedback neglected to mention the exact nature of your "problem" that was so serious and wrong. I think if you actually explained THAT, it might help. (send more feedback)

For instance, how did you get academically WORSE? I could remotely understand not learning anything, but how did you LOSE knowledge?

To answer your question, or at least attempt to, I would like to point out that life is full of MEANINGLESS rituals that serve no purpose other than sentimental moments.

Some examples of meaningless rituals include...

Marriage... Since most divorces end in divorce anyway, what is the point in celebrating a lifetime commitment that probably isn't? They should probably celebrate a marriage after like 10 years, and call it a SURVIVAL ceremony.

Christmas... What started as a religious celebration has turned in to economic mandate that sees most retailers selling in 6 weeks, the same they do all year.

Birthdays... Why do we celebrate a death march. Basically we are all going to die. We even publish a "life expectancy". So your birthday is really LIFE EXPECTANCY - BIRTHDAY = TIME LEFT. Assuming that you don't die in a horrible accident.

So.... Until you can provide additional persuasive evidence I still stick to my original advice in that you should let your parents come. Yes, they probably made mistakes. Yes, they failed you when you needed them, but you still say they were good parents, which means that they at least tried even if they failed.

Get used to the fact that life revolves around often meaningless social norms and start looking at the bright side of things instead of living in the past.

Get live advice from me on Blog Talk Radio
*** Check my Blog Talk Radio page for show times!!!

www.JudgeNeil.com / www.FreeAdviceCenter.com


Quick Reply
toggle
  Username:
Subject:
Body:
Security Code:
CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above in the box below

Submit
Active Forums 4.3


Select your audio application!


Applications not working?!?!?!
CLICK ME



Copyright 2010 by Neil A Strecker Privacy Statement|Terms Of Use Xhtml 1.0 CSS 2.1

);